25 Non-Candy Halloween Treat Ideas Kids Love!

If your kids are anything like mine, Halloween excitement starts long before October 31st. From costume planning to pumpkin patches, it’s one of the most magical times of the year – but it’s also one of the sweetest (and not always in a good way).

**This post contains affiliate links. I only recommend products I truly love. If you click and purchase, I may earn a small commission – at no cost to you.**

Between school parties, community events, and trick-or-treating, the candy overload can be real. Sticky fingers, sugar crashes, and the inevitable “just one more piece” meltdown? No thank you. That’s why every year, I look for non-candy Halloween treats that are just as fun, festive, and loved by kids – without the sugar rush.

Whether you’re putting together classroom goodies, handing out treats to trick-or-treaters, or assembling boo baskets for friends, here are 25 non-candy Halloween ideas that will make your house the favorite stop on the block.

These ideas are all kid-approved, allergy-friendly, and perfect for parents who want to bless, not stress this spooky season.

Fun and Playful Toys

1. Glow Sticks or Glow Bracelets– Glow sticks are a trick-or-treat essential. They’re inexpensive, fun for all ages, and help keep kids visible after dark. I love tossing a few in each bag – bonus points if you find the Halloween-themed ones shaped like bats or ghosts.
2. Halloween Bubble Tubes – Tiny bubble wands shaped like pumpkin or skeletons are an instant hit. They’re mess-free, easy to pack for classroom parties, and perfect for toddlers and preschoolers.
3. Mini Play-Doh Tubs – There’s something timeless about Play-Doh. Choose orange, black, or purple mini tubs and tie them with a small ribbon. You can even add a tiny cookie cutter for extra flair.
4. Stickers & Temporary Tattoos – You can never go wrong with stickers. Find cute ghost, cat, and candy corn designs, or opt for glow in the dark tattoos for a little extra fun.
5. Spider Rings & Vampire Fangs – A Halloween classic! These are inexpensive bulk buys that kids never tire of. Plus, they add a little spooky flair to any costume.

Creative & Crafty Ideas

1. Color-Your-Own Masks – Print or buy cardstock masks shaped like pumpkins, bats, or cats. Include a small crayon pack, and you’ve got a fun creative activity that doubles as a costume craft.
2. Mini Crayon Packs – Ideal for younger kids, mini crayon sets paired with a Halloween coloring sheet make the perfect non-messy goody bag filler.
3. Halloween Stamps – Self-inking stamps in fun designs – think witches, webs, and ghosts – are great for little hands and spark endless creativity.
4. Foam Sticker Sets – These soft foam stickers let kids decorate pumpkins, treat bags, or cards at home. They’re festive, tactile, and keep little ones busy post-party.
5. Glow-in-the-Dark Slime – Slime is still a hit with kids everywhere, and the glow-in-the-dark version adds the perfect spooky twist. You can find mini pre-made containers or make your own with glow paint for a DIY touch.

Healthier Snack Swaps

Sometimes, you just want to offer something edible without going full-sugar. These snacks keep things simple and allergy-friendly.

1. Apple Sauce Pouches – Kids love them, parents appreciation them, and you can make them festive by adding a cute ghost sticker or “Boo!” label.
2. Popcorn Bags – Try mini packs like Boom Chicka Pop or SkinnyPop, or make your own in orange cellophane bags with a printable Halloween tag.
3. Mini Pretzel Bags – Look for bat or pumpkin shapes to keep things festive. They’re a great salty alternative to sweets.
4. Fruit Leather or Fruit Strips – Made with real fruit, these feel like candy but skip the artificial dyes and sugar overload.
5. Snack Sized Trail Mix – Perfect for older kids, trail mix is a satisfying grab-and-go snack. For allergy-sensitive classrooms, use nut-free mixes with seeds, dried fruit, and cereal pieces.

Cute Keepsakes & Little Gifts

Non-edible goodies don’t have to be junky. Choose small items that kids will actually keep and use.

1. Mini Notebooks – Tiny journals with ghost or pumpkin covers are great for doodling or writing.
2. Erasers & Pencils – Grab a bundle of festive pencil toppers or mini eraser sets – perfect for school age kids.
3. Bookmarks – For a cozy fall twist, add printed bookmarks with encouraging or faith-based messages. They double as sweet reminders for older kids who are learning to read.
4. Mini Puzzle Packs – These pocket-sized puzzles are perfect for quiet time or travel. You can even find Halloween crossword or maze books.
5. Halloween Keychains – Kids love clipping these onto backpacks or lunchboxes. Soft rubber ghost or pumpkin ones are adorable and durable.

Boo Basket & Trick-or-Treat Faves

These items are ideal for small boo baskets, classroom exchanges, or neighborhood surprises.

1. Mini Rubber Ducks – Yes, there are alloween ducks – dressed as witches, vampires, and mummies. They’re cute, collectible, and great for bath time.
2. Wind-Up Toys – Hopping pumpkins and walking skeletons never fail to make kids laugh. They’re small enough to throw in any treat bag.
3. Pop-It Keychains – Still trending and and perfect for sensory play. Choose ghosts or pumpkins in any color palate!
4. Reusable Stick On Window Clings – Parents love these – no sugar, no cleanup. Let kids decorate their windows or mirrors with festive bats and ghosts.
5. Mini Plushies – Soft, tiny stuffed animals or Halloween characters are a sweet surprise for special friends or teacher gifts.

Why Non-Candy Treats Are Totally Worth It

Choosing non-candy Halloween treats doesn’t mean you’re the boring house. In fact, many kids get just as excited – sometimes more! – when they find something different in their bucket.

It also makes Halloween more inclusive for kids with food allergies, diabetes, or dietary restrictions. Parents will thank you for offering an option their little ones can enjoy without worry.

Plus, these treats last longer than candy and can keep the Halloween magic going for weeks. From glow sticks that light up the night to small toys they can play with again and again, these thoughtful swaps prove that Halloween can be fun and balanced.

Tips for Packaging You Non-Candy Treats

If you’re making your own treat bags, presentation makes all the difference!

• Use clear or Halloween themed cellophane bags tied with soft orange, black, or purple ribbons.
• Add a printable “Boo!” tag or “You’ve Been Booed” card.
• Mix one playful item (like a toy or sticker) with one practicle item (like a pencil or snack).
• For classrooms, always check with teachers about allergy guidelines before including any food items.

Wrapping It All Up

Halloween doesn’t have to revolve around candy. By mixing creative toys, simple crafts, and a few better-for-you-snacks, you can create fun, inclusive treats every child will enjoy – and every parent will appreciate.

So whether you’re building classroom goodie bags, surprise boo baskets, or handing out treats at the door, these 25 ideas make it easy to bless, not stress this Halloween season.